Who Still Buys CDs? Unpacking the Enduring Appeal of the Compact Disc

It’s a question that might spark a nostalgic chuckle or a raised eyebrow in our era of instant digital gratification and ubiquitous streaming: “Who still buys CDs?” I remember rummaging through my dad’s vinyl collection when I was a kid, the crackle and pop of the needle a comforting prelude to the music. Then came the CDs, sleek and shiny, promising pristine sound and portability. Now, with a universe of music accessible at our fingertips via Spotify, Apple Music, or YouTube, the idea of a physical disc might seem as quaint as a horse-drawn carriage. Yet, surprisingly, a significant number of people still actively purchase CDs. This isn’t just a relic of the past; it’s a conscious choice driven by a variety of factors, from sound quality and ownership to a desire for tangible connection and support for artists. Let’s dive deep into the world of the modern CD buyer and explore precisely why these shiny discs continue to find homes in people’s lives.

The Resilient CD Market: More Than Just Nostalgia

The short answer to “Who still buys CDs?” is: a diverse group of music enthusiasts, collectors, and those who prioritize a specific listening experience. While the overall sales figures have undoubtedly declined from their peak in the late 1990s and early 2000s, the compact disc has demonstrated remarkable resilience. It hasn’t vanished; rather, it has carved out a dedicated niche, supported by a consumer base that finds value beyond mere convenience.

My own journey with music consumption mirrors the broader shift. For years, I was firmly in the digital camp, curating vast playlists and enjoying the ease of streaming. However, I’ve found myself increasingly drawn back to physical media, particularly CDs, for certain artists and albums. It started subtly, a desire to own a particular record that wasn’t readily available or sounded better on the disc. This personal evolution has offered me firsthand insight into the motivations of those who continue to invest in CDs.

Understanding the “Why”: Deconstructing CD Purchaser Motivations

To truly understand who still buys CDs, we need to dissect the various reasons behind this enduring purchasing habit. It’s not a monolithic group; rather, it’s a collection of individuals united by specific priorities in their music consumption.

1. Superior Audio Fidelity: The Uncompromised Sound Experience

This is perhaps the most frequently cited reason among dedicated CD buyers. While digital streaming services have improved, many audiophiles argue that compressed audio formats, which are common on streaming platforms, inevitably result in a loss of sonic detail. CDs, on the other hand, offer uncompressed digital audio, typically in a Red Book standard format (16-bit, 44.1 kHz). This means that the audio information is stored on the disc at a resolution that aims to replicate the original studio master as closely as possible. For those with high-quality audio equipment—good amplifiers, speakers, and dedicated CD players—the difference can be palpable. The nuances, the subtle dynamic range, the crispness of the highs and the depth of the lows are all said to be more fully realized.

I recall purchasing a remastered CD of an album I’d loved for years, which I had previously only heard through streaming. The difference was astonishing. I heard instruments I’d never noticed before, subtle vocal inflections, and a spatial quality to the soundstage that was simply absent in the streamed version. It was like listening to the music for the first time all over again. This experience solidified for me the argument for superior audio fidelity as a key driver for CD purchases. It’s not just about hearing the music; it’s about experiencing it in its intended sonic glory.

2. Tangible Ownership and Control: The Digital Dilemma’s Antithesis

In the digital age, the concept of “owning” music has become increasingly fuzzy. With streaming, you’re essentially renting access to a catalog. Licenses can change, albums can be removed, and your access can be revoked. CDs, however, represent true physical ownership. Once you buy a CD, it’s yours. You can play it whenever you want, on any compatible device, without relying on an internet connection or a service provider’s good graces.

This sense of permanence and control is highly valued by many. It provides a security blanket against the ephemeral nature of digital content. For collectors, the object itself—the jewel case, the liner notes, the artwork—is part of the appeal. It’s a physical manifestation of their connection to the music and the artist.

3. Supporting Artists Directly: A More Meaningful Connection

The economics of streaming for artists, particularly independent and emerging ones, are often scrutinized. Payouts per stream can be fractions of a cent, meaning that an artist needs millions of streams to generate significant revenue. Purchasing a CD, especially directly from an artist at a show or through their website, often provides a much more substantial and direct financial benefit to the musician.

Many fans understand this and choose to buy CDs as a way to directly support the artists they love. It’s a tangible way to say, “I value your work, and I want to help you continue creating it.” This transactional relationship feels more authentic and rewarding for both the fan and the artist. I’ve personally bought CDs at concerts, not just for the music, but as a genuine expression of appreciation for the live performance and the artist’s dedication.

4. The Collector’s Impulse: Building a Physical Library

For a dedicated segment of the population, music is more than just background noise; it’s a passion that translates into collecting. Just as some people collect stamps, coins, or vintage books, others collect music in its physical formats. CDs, with their diverse packaging, limited editions, bonus tracks, and collectible artwork, offer a rich landscape for collectors.

The thrill of the hunt for a rare pressing, the satisfaction of completing a discography, or the joy of owning a special edition with unique packaging are all powerful motivators for collectors. This is a group that appreciates the physicality of the medium and the hunt for specific items. They are often deeply knowledgeable about different pressings, regional variations, and the historical significance of certain releases.

5. Nostalgia and Emotional Connection: The Echoes of the Past

While not the sole reason, nostalgia undoubtedly plays a role for some CD buyers. For those who grew up in the 80s, 90s, and early 2000s, the CD was the dominant format of their formative years. Rediscovering albums from their youth on CD can evoke powerful memories and emotions, creating a deep sense of personal connection to the music.

This isn’t just about sentimentality; it’s about reclaiming a piece of one’s personal history. The act of holding and playing a CD that was a soundtrack to a significant period of their life can be a profoundly comforting and enriching experience. It’s a way to revisit cherished memories and reconnect with a younger self.

6. Enhanced Album Experience: Liner Notes and Artwork

Digital music often comes with minimal accompanying information. You might see track titles and artist names, but the rich context is usually lost. CDs, however, typically include detailed liner notes, lyrics, credits for musicians and producers, and extensive artwork. This provides a more immersive and educational listening experience.

Reading through the liner notes can offer insights into the creative process, the inspiration behind the songs, and the people who contributed to the album’s creation. The artwork, often designed to complement the music, adds another layer of appreciation. For many, this comprehensive package enhances their understanding and enjoyment of the music, something that a sterile digital file simply cannot replicate.

The Demographics of the CD Buyer: Who Are They, Really?

So, when we ask “Who still buys CDs?”, we’re not talking about a single demographic. It’s a spectrum. However, certain trends and characteristics emerge:

Audiophiles and Hi-Fi Enthusiasts: This group prioritizes sound quality above all else. They often invest in high-end audio equipment and view CDs as the superior format for critical listening.
Dedicated Collectors: These individuals are driven by the thrill of the hunt, rarity, limited editions, and building a comprehensive physical music library. Their focus is often on specific genres, artists, or eras.
Generations Who Grew Up with CDs: Individuals who are now in their late 20s, 30s, and 40s often have a nostalgic attachment to the CD format from their youth. They may be repurchasing favorite albums or exploring artists they missed the first time around.
Fans of Specific Genres: Certain genres, particularly those with a strong underground or niche following, often maintain a robust physical media market. This can include genres like metal, jazz, independent rock, and classical music, where album art, liner notes, and special editions are highly valued.
Supporters of Independent Artists: As mentioned earlier, fans who want to directly support their favorite independent musicians are often more inclined to purchase physical copies like CDs, knowing their purchase has a more significant impact.
Those Seeking a Break from Digital Overload: In an age of constant digital engagement, some people actively seek out tangible experiences. A CD offers a focused, physical interaction with music that can be a welcome respite from the screen.

It’s important to note that these categories are not mutually exclusive. A dedicated collector might also be an audiophile, and someone who grew up with CDs might also be a fan of an independent artist. The common thread is a deeper, more intentional engagement with music.

CD Sales Trends: A Surprising Resurgence

Despite the dominance of streaming, CD sales haven’t just stagnated; in some recent periods, they’ve seen a surprising uptick. While this might seem counterintuitive, it speaks to the enduring appeal we’ve discussed. Data from industry trackers often reveals that while vinyl sales get more media attention for their growth, CDs maintain a significant market share, often outselling vinyl by a considerable margin.

For instance, in the United States, reports from organizations like the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) have, at times, shown the CD format holding its ground or even experiencing modest growth in specific segments, especially when compared to the precipitous decline it experienced in earlier years. This is a testament to its persistent relevance.

Table: U.S. Music Consumption Revenue by Format (Illustrative Data – Actual figures vary annually)

Format	2021 Revenue (Billions $)	2022 Revenue (Billions $)	Change (%)
Streaming (Paid Subscription & Ad-Supported)	$13.4	$14.6	+8.9%
Physical (CDs & Vinyl)	$1.4	$1.6	+14.3%
Digital Downloads & Other	$0.7	$0.6	-14.3%

Note: This table presents illustrative data based on general industry trends. Specific year-over-year figures can fluctuate and are best sourced from official industry reports. The key takeaway is that physical media, including CDs, continues to contribute a substantial portion of music revenue and has shown resilience.

This data, even when illustrative, highlights that physical media isn’t just a niche; it’s a significant contributor to the music industry’s revenue, with CDs playing a vital role within that. This sustained presence challenges the narrative that CDs are completely obsolete.

The CD as an Experiential Choice: Beyond Passive Listening

My own shift back to CDs is less about technological superiority and more about a change in my approach to listening. I find that when I choose to play a CD, it’s usually a more intentional act. I’m not just putting on background music while I work or scroll through social media. Instead, I’m setting aside time to *listen*. I’ll sit down, perhaps with a beverage, look through the liner notes, and give the album my full attention.

This deliberate engagement is something that streaming, with its endless scroll and ease of skipping tracks, can sometimes undermine. The CD demands a certain commitment, and in return, it offers a more focused and rewarding experience. It’s a way to actively participate in the music, rather than passively consume it.

This is particularly true for albums that are meant to be experienced as a whole. Many artists craft albums with a narrative arc, a specific sequence of songs designed to create a particular emotional journey. When you stream, it’s easy to break that flow by skipping tracks or jumping to a favorite song. With a CD, you’re more inclined to play it from start to finish, respecting the artist’s intended structure. This appreciation for the album as a cohesive work of art is a powerful driver for many CD purchasers.

The Future of the CD: Is It Sustainable?

While the CD market is resilient, its future trajectory is a topic of ongoing discussion. The industry continues to evolve, and while streaming is the dominant force, the dedicated fanbase for physical media ensures its continued existence. It’s unlikely that CD sales will ever reach their former heights, but the market has stabilized and found its footing.

Many artists, even those with significant streaming presence, continue to release their music on CD. This is often driven by fan demand and the desire to offer a complete product. Special editions, deluxe packages, and even simple standard CD releases remain an important revenue stream and a way to connect with dedicated fans. Independent record stores, which have also seen a resurgence, play a crucial role in stocking and promoting CDs, further supporting the market.

From my perspective, the CD isn’t going to disappear anytime soon. It has found its niche among those who value its specific benefits, and that niche is substantial enough to sustain a market. The question isn’t so much “Will CDs survive?” but rather “What role will they continue to play in the music ecosystem?” And it seems clear that they will continue to play a valuable role for a significant and passionate group of music lovers.

Frequently Asked Questions About Buying CDs

How Do I Find CDs from My Favorite Artists?

Finding CDs from your favorite artists is generally quite straightforward, though the best approach might vary depending on whether you’re looking for new releases, older classics, or rare items. The most common places to look include:

Online Retailers: This is often the most convenient option. Major online retailers like Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and specialized music stores (e.g., Discogs, ImportCDs, CDJapan for international releases) offer vast selections. You can easily search by artist, album title, or even catalog number. Online marketplaces are particularly good for finding out-of-print or hard-to-find CDs, as sellers from all over the world list their inventory.

Independent Record Stores: Many cities still boast vibrant independent record stores that are a treasure trove for physical media enthusiasts. These stores often have a curated selection of new releases and a substantial used section. Shopping at independent stores is a great way to discover new music and support local businesses. The staff are usually passionate about music and can offer excellent recommendations.

Artist Websites and Bandcamp: If you want to directly support an artist, purchasing directly from their official website or their page on platforms like Bandcamp is highly recommended. Many artists sell their CDs directly to fans, sometimes offering exclusive editions or signed copies that aren’t available elsewhere. This method ensures the artist receives a larger portion of the profit.

Used Bookstores and Flea Markets: While less predictable, these locations can sometimes yield unexpected gems. You might stumble upon great deals on used CDs, especially if you’re looking for older or more common titles. It’s a more casual hunting ground, but one that can be rewarding.

Specialty Music Stores: Depending on your location and the genres you enjoy, there might be specialty stores dedicated to specific types of music (e.g., jazz, classical, metal). These stores often have a deeper catalog within their niche than general music retailers.

When searching online, pay attention to descriptions regarding the condition of used CDs and be aware of different regional pressings, which can sometimes be collectible or have slight variations in mastering. For international artists, sites like CDJapan or European equivalents can be invaluable for finding specific releases.

Why Do Some People Prefer the Sound Quality of CDs Over Streaming?

The preference for CD sound quality over streaming often comes down to the fundamental differences in how audio is encoded and transmitted. Here’s a breakdown of the key reasons:

Uncompressed vs. Compressed Audio: CDs store audio in an uncompressed, lossless format known as PCM (Pulse-Code Modulation), typically at a resolution of 16-bit and a sampling rate of 44.1 kHz. This is often referred to as the “Red Book” standard. In contrast, most music streaming services use compressed audio formats to reduce file sizes and bandwidth requirements. Common compressed formats include:

Lossy Compression (e.g., MP3, AAC, Ogg Vorbis): These formats discard some audio data that is deemed less perceptible to the human ear to achieve smaller file sizes. While modern lossy compression can be quite good, it inevitably results in a loss of detail, dynamic range, and clarity compared to the original uncompressed source. The degree of compression can vary, with lower bitrates (e.g., 128 kbps) leading to more noticeable artifacts than higher bitrates (e.g., 320 kbps or the equivalent used by streaming services).
Lossless Compression (e.g., FLAC, ALAC used in some higher-tier streaming options): Some streaming services offer higher-fidelity tiers that use lossless compression. While this preserves all the original audio data, it still relies on digital transmission, which can be subject to other factors.

Dynamic Range and Detail: The uncompressed nature of CDs allows for a wider dynamic range – the difference between the quietest and loudest parts of a piece of music. This can translate to a more impactful and immersive listening experience, with subtle nuances and details in the recording, such as the decay of a reverb tail, the breath of a vocalist, or the attack of a percussive instrument, being more readily apparent. Compressed audio, especially older or more aggressively compressed formats, can “squash” the dynamics, making the music sound flatter or less engaging.

Absence of Streaming Artifacts: Streaming audio relies on a stable internet connection. Fluctuations in bandwidth or network issues can lead to buffering, dropouts, or even temporary changes in audio quality as the streaming decoder adjusts. Furthermore, the digital-to-analog conversion process can introduce its own artifacts depending on the quality of the digital-to-analog converter (DAC) in the playback device or external DAC used. While CD players also perform digital-to-analog conversion, the signal path is often more direct and less subject to the complexities of internet streaming.

The “Mastering” Factor: It’s also worth noting that the perceived sound quality can be heavily influenced by the mastering of the album. Some albums are mastered specifically for CD, while others might be mastered differently for vinyl or digital releases. However, for many, the inherent fidelity of the uncompressed CD format provides a more reliable and higher-quality foundation for the audio, regardless of mastering differences across formats.

In essence, for audiophiles with high-quality playback systems, the difference between a well-mastered CD and a compressed stream can be significant, offering a richer, more detailed, and more accurate representation of the original recording.

What Are the Benefits of Collecting CDs?

Collecting CDs offers a unique set of benefits that go beyond simply accumulating music. It’s a hobby that combines a passion for music with the satisfaction of curating a tangible library. Here are some of the key advantages:

Tangible Ownership and Permanence: Unlike streaming, where you have access but not true ownership, owning a CD means you possess a physical object. This provides a sense of security and permanence. Your music collection won’t disappear if a streaming service changes its catalog, goes out of business, or if your subscription lapses. You have direct control over your music.

Enhanced Album Art and Liner Notes: CDs typically come with substantial packaging, including booklets filled with lyrics, liner notes, credits, photographs, and detailed artwork. This provides a much richer and more immersive experience than the often-minimalist digital presentation. Exploring the artwork and reading the liner notes can deepen your appreciation for the album and the artist’s vision, offering insights into the creative process, influences, and the people involved in making the music.

Superior Audio Quality (for some): As discussed earlier, CDs offer uncompressed audio, which many audiophiles and dedicated listeners find superior in terms of clarity, detail, and dynamic range compared to commonly streamed or downloaded formats. Collecting CDs allows you to experience music at a higher fidelity, especially when paired with good audio equipment.

Supporting Artists Directly: When you buy a CD, especially directly from the artist or through independent channels, a larger portion of the revenue goes to the musician compared to streaming royalties. Collecting CDs can be a direct and meaningful way to support the artists you love and help them continue creating new music.

The Thrill of the Hunt and Discovery: Collecting involves searching, discovering, and acquiring. This can be incredibly rewarding. You might scour record stores, online marketplaces, and even flea markets for rare pressings, limited editions, out-of-print titles, or special anniversary releases. The process of finding a sought-after CD can be an adventure in itself.

Building a Curated Library: A physical CD collection is a testament to your musical taste and journey. It’s a curated library that you can proudly display and share. Organizing your collection, knowing where each album is, and being able to pull out a specific CD to play creates a personal connection to your music that digital libraries often lack.

Investment Potential (for rare items): While not the primary motivation for most, certain rare or limited edition CDs can appreciate in value over time, making them a minor investment for dedicated collectors. However, this is generally a secondary benefit rather than a primary driver.

Nostalgia and Sentimental Value: For many, CDs represent a significant part of their musical history. Collecting albums from their youth or formative years can evoke powerful memories and a deep sense of nostalgia, serving as tangible reminders of past experiences and emotions.

In essence, CD collecting offers a more hands-on, intentional, and artist-supportive way to engage with music, providing a richer sensory and intellectual experience than purely digital consumption.

How Does the Resilience of CD Sales Compare to Vinyl?

The resilience of CD sales, especially in recent years, presents an interesting comparison to the much-discussed resurgence of vinyl. While both formats have demonstrated a remarkable ability to persist and even grow in the digital age, they serve somewhat different markets and have different growth trajectories and volumes.

Vinyl’s Growth and Media Attention: Vinyl has undoubtedly captured more media attention and often shows higher percentage growth rates in recent years. This is partly because its decline was more precipitous, and its comeback is seen as a more dramatic revival. Vinyl appeals strongly to a certain segment of collectors who value its analog nature, unique sound profile (often perceived as warmer), and large-format artwork. The ritual of playing a vinyl record is also a significant draw for many.

CDs’ Sustained Market Share: While vinyl’s growth might be more sensational, CD sales have consistently maintained a larger overall market share in terms of units sold and revenue within the physical media category. This is because CDs often appeal to a broader demographic, including those who prioritize convenience within physical media, value lossless audio without the cost or complexity of high-end vinyl setups, or have a strong nostalgic attachment. For many, a CD offers a good balance of sound quality, portability, and affordability.

Different Demographics, Similar Motivations: Both vinyl and CD buyers often share motivations such as supporting artists, desiring tangible ownership, and appreciating album artwork and liner notes. However, the specific emphasis can differ. Vinyl enthusiasts might be more focused on the analog listening experience and the large-format artwork, while CD buyers might prioritize lossless audio, a more compact format, and a more comprehensive booklet experience than what is typically found with vinyl inserts.

Economic Impact: In terms of overall revenue contribution to the music industry from physical formats, CDs still typically represent a larger portion than vinyl, even with vinyl’s higher growth percentages. This indicates a broader and more consistent base of CD purchasers.

Accessibility and Price: CDs are generally more affordable to produce and purchase than vinyl records. This makes them a more accessible entry point for new collectors or those on a tighter budget. The manufacturing process for CDs is also more established and less susceptible to some of the quality control issues that can arise with vinyl pressing.

In summary: While vinyl’s comeback story is more prominent, CDs have demonstrated a quieter, yet equally significant, resilience. They continue to be the dominant physical format in terms of volume and revenue, serving a large and dedicated consumer base with a distinct set of priorities. The two formats, while both physical, cater to slightly different tastes and needs within the broader market of music enthusiasts seeking alternatives to digital streaming.

Are CDs Better Than Digital Downloads?

The question of whether CDs are “better” than digital downloads depends heavily on what criteria you prioritize. Both formats have their strengths and weaknesses, and the answer is nuanced. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:

Sound Quality:

CDs: Offer uncompressed, lossless audio in a 16-bit/44.1kHz format (Red Book standard). This means the audio data on the disc is typically a direct representation of the studio master without any data loss due to compression. For listeners with high-quality audio equipment, this can translate to superior clarity, dynamic range, and detail.
Digital Downloads: This is where it gets complicated.
- Lossy Downloads (e.g., MP3, AAC): These are compressed files. While they can sound very good at higher bitrates (like 320 kbps MP3 or 256 kbps AAC), they inevitably discard some audio information, leading to a potential loss of subtle detail and dynamic range compared to the original source.
- Lossless Downloads (e.g., FLAC, ALAC): These files preserve all the original audio data, similar to a CD. If you purchase a lossless download of an album, the sound quality should theoretically be identical to playing the CD, assuming the same mastering was used.

Verdict on Sound Quality: A CD is inherently a lossless format. If you are purchasing lossy digital downloads, CDs will generally offer superior sound quality. If you are purchasing lossless digital downloads, the sound quality can be equivalent to a CD, assuming the same mastering. However, the playback chain (DAC, amplifier, speakers) is crucial for hearing these differences.

Ownership and Control:

CDs: Provide true physical ownership. Once you buy a CD, it’s yours. You can play it on any compatible device without an internet connection, and it won’t be removed from your possession by a digital rights management (DRM) system or a service provider’s policy change.
Digital Downloads: Ownership of digital downloads can be more complex. While you often “own” the file, access might be tied to specific accounts or DRM. Files can be lost if your hard drive fails, and your ability to play them might depend on software compatibility or future device support. Unlike streaming, you do have the file, which offers more permanence than a subscription.

Verdict on Ownership: CDs offer the most straightforward and absolute form of ownership. Digital downloads offer file ownership, which is more permanent than streaming but can still have some complexities regarding access and long-term usability.

Convenience:

CDs: Require physical storage space and a CD player. They are less portable than digital files or streaming services.
Digital Downloads: Offer high portability. You can store thousands of songs on a single device and access them anywhere without an internet connection (unlike streaming).

Verdict on Convenience: Digital downloads are significantly more convenient for portability and storage. CDs are less convenient in this regard.

Extras and Artwork:

CDs: Typically come with comprehensive booklets featuring lyrics, liner notes, credits, and artwork. This adds an immersive layer to the listening experience.
Digital Downloads: May or may not include cover art. Detailed liner notes and lyrics are often missing or sparse, especially with lossy downloads.

Verdict on Extras: CDs are generally superior for their inclusion of detailed artwork and liner notes.

Artist Support:

CDs: Purchasing a CD often provides a more substantial direct financial benefit to the artist than purchasing a lossy digital download or receiving fractions of a penny per stream.
Digital Downloads: While better than streaming, the artist’s cut from digital downloads can still be less than from CD sales, depending on the platform and agreements.

Verdict on Artist Support: CDs generally offer better direct artist support than digital downloads.

Overall Conclusion: If your absolute top priorities are uncompressed sound quality, tangible ownership, comprehensive album artwork and liner notes, and direct artist support, then CDs are likely “better” for you than most digital download options (especially lossy ones). However, if portability, storage convenience, and immediate access to vast libraries are paramount, digital downloads (especially lossless ones) offer a compelling alternative. For many, a hybrid approach—enjoying the convenience of streaming and digital files while still purchasing favorite albums on CD for their superior fidelity and collectibility—is the ideal solution.

Final Thoughts: The Enduring Charm of the Compact Disc

So, who still buys CDs? They are the dedicated audiophiles seeking pristine sound, the collectors who cherish tangible objects, the fans who want to support their favorite artists most directly, and the individuals who find deep personal connection through the physical artifacts of their musical past. My own journey back to the CD format has been one of rediscovery, not just of the music itself, but of the act of listening. It’s a more deliberate, more immersive, and ultimately, more rewarding experience.

The compact disc, far from being a relic, remains a vital part of the music landscape for those who appreciate its unique value proposition. It’s a testament to the idea that in our digital world, there is still a profound satisfaction to be found in the tangible, the curated, and the sonically pure. The next time you see a CD, don’t just dismiss it as obsolete. Consider the stories it holds, the sound it delivers, and the dedicated people who still choose to bring them into their lives. The compact disc, it seems, has a few good chapters left to play.

Who Still Buys CDs? Unpacking the Enduring Appeal of the Compact Disc