How Long Can Plants Go Without Water? Factors Determining Plant Survival and Drought Tolerance
The Age-Old Question: How Long Can Plants Go Without Water?
I remember that one summer, visiting my aunt’s house out in Arizona. She’s got this amazing desert garden, full of cacti and succulents that look like they belong on another planet. I, on the other hand, come from a place where everything is perpetually green and lush, so her arid landscape was a real eye-opener. One afternoon, while she was out of town for a few days, a heatwave hit. I’d completely forgotten to water her prize-winning prickly pear cactus. When I finally remembered, a full week had passed since its last drink. My heart sank. I was convinced it was a goner. But to my astonishment, after I gave it a good soaking, it bounced back like nothing had happened! This experience got me thinking – just how resilient are plants, really? And what makes some able to endure a drought while others wilt away in a matter of days? Understanding how long plants can go without water is crucial for any gardener, plant enthusiast, or even just someone trying to keep their houseplants alive. It’s not a simple one-size-fits-all answer; rather, it depends on a fascinating interplay of factors.
So, to directly answer the question, how long can plants go without water? It varies dramatically, ranging from a few days for sensitive plants to several months or even years for exceptionally drought-tolerant species. This wide spectrum is due to a complex array of biological adaptations, environmental conditions, and plant life stages. Let’s dive deep into what influences a plant’s ability to survive dry spells.
Understanding Plant Water Needs: The Foundation of Survival
Before we delve into drought tolerance, it’s essential to grasp why plants need water in the first place. Water is the lifeblood of a plant, playing several critical roles:
- Photosynthesis: This is how plants create their food. Water is a key ingredient, along with carbon dioxide and sunlight. Without enough water, this vital process grinds to a halt.
- Nutrient Transport: Water acts as a solvent, dissolving minerals and nutrients from the soil. This nutrient-rich water is then transported throughout the plant, from the roots to the leaves, feeding every part.
- Turgor Pressure: Think of this as the internal water pressure within plant cells. Turgor pressure is what keeps plants firm and upright. When water levels drop, cells lose turgor, leading to wilting.
- Temperature Regulation: Through transpiration (the release of water vapor from leaves), plants cool themselves down, much like sweating cools us.
- Structural Support: While not the primary function, turgor pressure contributes significantly to a plant’s rigidity.
When a plant doesn’t receive enough water, it enters a state of drought stress. Initially, it will show signs of wilting as it tries to conserve water. If the stress continues, it can lead to a cascade of physiological responses, ultimately culminating in cell damage and death if the water deficit is too severe or prolonged.
Factors That Dictate Drought Survival Time
Now, let’s explore the nitty-gritty of what makes one plant a champion of the dry spell while another succumbs quickly.
1. Plant Type and Species-Specific Adaptations
This is perhaps the most significant factor. Different plant families and species have evolved a remarkable range of adaptations to survive in environments with scarce water.
- Succulents and Cacti: These are the superstars of drought tolerance. My aunt’s prickly pear cactus is a prime example. They have evolved specialized tissues to store large amounts of water in their leaves, stems, or roots. Their waxy coatings and reduced leaf surface area (or even absence of leaves, as in many cacti) minimize water loss through transpiration. They can often go for months without water, especially when dormant.
- Drought-Tolerant Shrubs and Trees: Many plants native to arid or semi-arid regions have developed strategies like deep root systems to tap into groundwater, small or needle-like leaves to reduce surface area, and a thicker cuticle (outer layer) to prevent evaporation. Examples include olive trees, oleander, and many varieties of acacia. These might survive weeks to months without water, depending on the severity of the conditions.
- Annuals and Tender Perennials: Plants that complete their life cycle in one season (annuals) or those that are not hardy in colder climates (tender perennials) often have a much lower tolerance for drought. They typically have less developed root systems and are geared towards rapid growth during favorable (i.e., wet) periods. Many of these can start to show significant wilting within a few days of being deprived of water, especially in hot weather.
- Grasses: While some grasses are remarkably drought-tolerant (think of prairie grasses that can survive scorching summers), others, especially those cultivated for lawns in temperate regions, can be quite thirsty. Many lawn grasses will go dormant during drought, turning brown, but can often recover once water is available again.
- Vegetables and Herbs: This is a mixed bag. Some herbs like rosemary, thyme, and lavender are quite drought-tolerant once established. Many vegetables, however, especially fruiting ones like tomatoes and peppers, have consistently high water needs and can suffer significantly if they don’t receive regular moisture, leading to reduced yields or blossom end rot. Leafy greens are particularly sensitive.
My own experiments with herbs have shown this beautifully. A pot of basil on my windowsill will droop dramatically after just a day or two without water in the summer, while a potted rosemary plant can often go a week or more and still look quite perky. It’s all about their inherent design.
2. Environmental Conditions
Even the most drought-tolerant plant will struggle under extreme conditions. Several environmental factors play a crucial role in how quickly a plant dehydrates:
- Temperature: Higher temperatures increase the rate of evaporation from the soil and transpiration from the plant’s leaves. On a scorching hot day, a plant will use water much faster than on a cool, overcast day.
- Humidity: Low humidity levels mean there’s a greater difference in water vapor concentration between the plant’s leaves and the surrounding air, driving faster transpiration. High humidity slows this process down.
- Wind: Wind can dry out plants very quickly. It increases the rate of transpiration by removing the humid layer of air that surrounds a leaf. Strong, dry winds are particularly detrimental.
- Sunlight Intensity: Intense sunlight can lead to increased photosynthesis and, consequently, higher water demand. It also contributes to higher leaf temperatures, further increasing transpiration.
- Soil Type: Different soil types retain moisture differently.
- Sandy soils: Drain very quickly and don’t hold much water, meaning plants in sandy soil will dry out faster.
- Clay soils: Hold water for much longer but can become waterlogged if overwatered, which is detrimental to root health. However, once they do dry out, they can become very hard and restrict water uptake.
- Loam soils: A good balance of sand, silt, and clay, generally offering good drainage and moisture retention.
- Container vs. In-Ground: Plants in containers dry out significantly faster than those planted directly in the ground. This is because their root systems are confined, and the soil in pots is more exposed to sun, wind, and air circulation, leading to quicker evaporation.
I’ve noticed this repeatedly with my houseplants. A ficus tree in a large pot on my patio will need watering far more often than a similar-sized tree planted in the ground in my backyard, especially during the summer. The pot just acts like a sponge that dries out quickly.
3. Plant’s Life Stage and Health
A plant’s age and overall health also impact its ability to withstand drought.
- Young Plants/Seedlings: Young plants have less developed root systems and are generally more vulnerable to drought. They need consistent moisture to establish.
- Established Plants: Mature plants with well-developed root systems are typically much more drought-tolerant. They can access deeper water sources and often have more reserves.
- Flowering or Fruiting Plants: Plants that are actively producing flowers or fruits have higher metabolic demands and thus higher water requirements. Drought during these critical periods can lead to flower or fruit drop and reduced yields.
- Overall Health: A healthy plant with good vigor is much better equipped to handle stress, including drought, than a plant that is already struggling with pests, diseases, or nutrient deficiencies.
4. Dormancy and Seasonal Cycles
Many plants have natural periods of dormancy where their metabolic activity slows down significantly. During dormancy, their water needs are drastically reduced.
- Winter Dormancy: Deciduous trees and many perennials go dormant in winter. They shed their leaves (in the case of deciduous plants) to conserve water and energy. While they still need some moisture to survive, their requirements are minimal.
- Summer Dormancy: Some plants, particularly those from Mediterranean climates or desert regions, may go dormant during hot, dry summers to avoid stress. They might shed leaves or reduce their growth rate until cooler, wetter conditions return.
This explains why some plants seem to die back completely in winter and then miraculously return in spring. They weren’t dead; they were just resting and conserving resources, including water.
Assessing Drought Stress: Recognizing the Signs
It’s crucial to be able to identify when your plants are starting to feel the heat (or lack thereof). Early detection can save a plant from irreversible damage.
Visual Cues of Drought Stress
The most obvious sign is wilting. However, the way a plant wilts and other associated symptoms can provide clues:
- Wilting: Leaves lose their turgor pressure and droop. This can range from a slight drooping to complete collapse of the foliage. Some plants, like ferns, wilt very dramatically and quickly.
- Leaf Drooping or Rolling: Some plants, like tomatoes or beans, will roll their leaves inward to reduce the exposed surface area.
- Yellowing Leaves (Chlorosis): As a plant conserves resources, it may start to shed older leaves, which often turn yellow before dropping. This is particularly common in houseplants.
- Leaf Drop: The plant sheds leaves to reduce water loss. This is a common defense mechanism.
- Crispy or Brown Leaf Edges: If drought is prolonged, the leaf tissue itself can begin to dry out and turn brown and brittle, starting from the edges.
- Stunted Growth: A plant not receiving enough water will slow or stop its growth, producing smaller leaves and shorter stems.
- Reduced Flowering or Fruiting: As mentioned, water stress will often cause flowers to drop prematurely or prevent fruits from developing properly.
- Changes in Soil Moisture: The soil surface may appear dry and cracked, and it might feel hard and compacted.
When to Water: The Finger Test and Beyond
The most reliable way to know if your plant needs water is to check the soil moisture.
- The Finger Test: This is a tried-and-true method, especially for potted plants. Stick your finger about an inch or two into the soil.
- If it feels dry, it’s probably time to water.
- If it feels moist, wait and check again later.
- Moisture Meter: For those who prefer a more precise method, a soil moisture meter can be very helpful. Stick the probe into the soil at the root level and read the moisture level.
- Lifting the Pot: For smaller potted plants, you can get a feel for how heavy the pot is. A dry pot will be significantly lighter than a moist one.
It’s always better to underwater slightly than to overwater, as overwatering can lead to root rot, a condition that is often more difficult to recover from than temporary drought stress. Root rot suffocates the roots, preventing them from absorbing water and nutrients, ironically leading to wilting symptoms similar to drought.
Strategies for Drought Survival and Management
Knowing how long plants can go without water is one thing; actively managing their water needs and helping them through dry spells is another.
Watering Wisely
The key to successful watering is consistency and depth:
- Water Deeply and Infrequently: This encourages roots to grow deeper into the soil, making the plant more resilient. Shallow, frequent watering only wets the top layer of soil, leading to shallow root systems that are more susceptible to drying out.
- Water at the Base: Avoid watering the foliage, especially during hot, sunny periods, as water droplets can act like tiny magnifying glasses and scorch leaves. Watering the soil directly ensures the roots get the moisture.
- Water in the Morning: This is generally the best time. It allows the plant to hydrate before the heat of the day, and any excess moisture on the leaves has time to evaporate, reducing the risk of fungal diseases. Evening watering can also work but might leave foliage wet overnight, increasing disease risk in humid climates.
- Know Your Plant’s Needs: Research the specific water requirements of your plants. Some love to dry out between waterings, while others prefer consistently moist soil.
Improving Soil Moisture Retention
For both potted plants and garden beds, improving the soil’s ability to hold water is crucial:
- Amend the Soil: Incorporate organic matter like compost, peat moss, or coco coir into your soil. These materials act like sponges, absorbing and retaining water.
- Mulching: Apply a layer of organic mulch (wood chips, straw, shredded bark) or inorganic mulch (gravel, landscape fabric) around the base of your plants. Mulch helps to:
- Reduce evaporation from the soil surface.
- Keep the soil temperature more consistent, preventing extreme heating and cooling.
- Suppress weeds, which compete with your plants for water.
I’ve found mulching to be a game-changer in my garden. Not only does it keep the soil moister for longer, but it also makes the garden beds look much tidier. Plus, it significantly cuts down on the weeding I have to do!
Choosing Drought-Tolerant Plants
Perhaps the most effective long-term strategy is to select plants that are naturally suited to your climate and conditions:
- Native Plants: Plants indigenous to your region have already adapted to the local rainfall patterns and soil types. They often require less supplemental watering and care once established.
- Xeriscaping: This is a landscaping method that focuses on water conservation. It involves choosing drought-tolerant plants, efficient irrigation, and appropriate mulching.
- Research Plant Tags: When buying plants, look for labels that indicate drought tolerance or suitability for dry climates.
In my area, I’ve started incorporating more native wildflowers and shrubs into my garden. They’ve proven to be incredibly resilient, needing very little attention even during dry spells, unlike some of the more “traditional” garden plants I used to rely on.
Specific Plant Examples and Their Drought Tolerance (A Comparative Look**)**
To further illustrate the vast differences in drought tolerance, let’s look at a few common plant examples:
| Plant Type | Example Species | Typical Drought Tolerance (Weeks/Months) | Key Adaptations |
| :——————- | :————————- | :————————————— | :————————————————————————————————————— |
| Succulent | Echeveria | Months | Fleshy leaves store water; thick cuticle; slow growth. |
| Cactus | Saguaro Cactus | Many Months to Years | Stems store vast amounts of water; reduced surface area (spines); CAM photosynthesis (opens stomata at night). |
| Herb | Rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis) | 3-6 Weeks | Deep root system; leathery, needle-like leaves reduce water loss. |
| Shrub | Lavender (Lavandula) | 3-5 Weeks | Fuzzy leaves reduce transpiration; deep roots. |
| Tree | Olive Tree (Olea europaea) | 4-8 Weeks+ | Deep root system; small, leathery leaves with waxy coating. |
| Vegetable | Tomato (Solanum lycopersicum) | Days to 1-2 Weeks | Requires consistent moisture, especially during fruiting; shallow root system compared to larger plants. |
| Vegetable | Lettuce (Lactuca sativa) | Days to 1 Week | High water content; shallow root system; sensitive to wilting. |
| Houseplant| Pothos (Epipremnum aureum) | 1-3 Weeks | Can tolerate drying out; stores some water in leaves and stems. |
| Houseplant| Fern (e.g., Boston Fern) | Days to 1 Week | High humidity needs; shallow roots; wilts very quickly when dry. |
Note: The “Weeks/Months” in the table are approximate and assume moderate temperatures and reasonable sunlight. In extreme heat and drought, these times can be significantly reduced. For plants in containers, the duration will also be shorter.
Common FAQs About Plant Water Needs
It’s natural to have questions when it comes to keeping plants hydrated. Here are some frequently asked questions and their detailed answers.
How do I know if my plant is getting too much or too little water?
Distinguishing between overwatering and underwatering can sometimes be tricky because the symptoms can appear similar, such as wilting and yellowing leaves. However, there are key differences to look for.
Signs of Underwatering:
- Wilting: The most classic sign. Leaves droop and lose their firmness. This is the plant’s way of conserving water by reducing the surface area exposed to the air and decreasing internal pressure.
- Dry, Crispy Leaf Edges: If the drought stress is prolonged, the leaf tissue itself can dry out, turning brown and brittle, often starting at the edges.
- Slowed or Stunted Growth: The plant won’t have the resources to grow. New leaves may be smaller than usual, and overall development will be significantly reduced.
- Soil Pulling Away from Pot Edges: As the soil dries out completely, it can shrink, creating a gap between the soil ball and the sides of the pot.
- Yellowing of Older Leaves: The plant may sacrifice older leaves to conserve water and nutrients for new growth. These leaves typically turn yellow before dropping.
Signs of Overwatering:
- Yellowing Leaves: This is a common symptom for both, but with overwatering, the yellowing might be more widespread, and the leaves might feel soft or mushy, rather than dry and brittle. Often, lower leaves are affected first.
- Wilting: Ironically, overwatered plants can also wilt. This happens because the roots, constantly sitting in waterlogged soil, begin to rot. Damaged roots cannot absorb water efficiently, leading to a dehydrated plant despite the abundance of water in the soil.
- Edema: This condition appears as blisters or water-soaked spots on the undersides of leaves, which can later turn corky or rough. It occurs when roots absorb water faster than the plant can transpire it.
- Root Rot: This is the most serious consequence of overwatering. The roots turn brown or black, smell foul, and become mushy and disintegrated. You might only discover this when repotting or if the plant collapses suddenly.
- Fungal Growth on Soil Surface: A persistently damp soil surface can encourage the growth of mold or fungus, sometimes appearing as a white, fuzzy layer.
- Stunted Growth: Just like with underwatering, overwatering can also lead to stunted growth because the roots are damaged and unable to function properly.
How to Differentiate: The best way to tell is to check the soil moisture. If the soil is bone dry an inch or two down, it’s likely underwatering. If the soil is consistently wet and soggy, even days after watering, it’s likely overwatering. Also, consider the feel of the leaves – dry and crisp suggests underwatering, while soft, mushy, or yellow leaves can indicate overwatering.
How often should I water my plants?
This is perhaps the most asked question in gardening, and unfortunately, there’s no single, universal answer. The frequency of watering depends on a multitude of factors, including:
- Plant Type: As we’ve discussed, a cactus needs far less water than a fern.
- Pot Size and Material: Small pots and terracotta pots dry out much faster than larger pots or plastic/glazed pots.
- Soil Type: Sandy soils require more frequent watering than clay soils.
- Environmental Conditions: Plants in hot, sunny, windy, or low-humidity environments will need water much more frequently than those in cooler, shadier, humid conditions.
- Season: Plants generally need more water during their active growing season (spring and summer) and much less during dormancy (winter).
- Light Exposure: Plants receiving more direct sunlight will transpire more water.
Instead of focusing on a rigid schedule, it’s far more effective to water based on the plant’s needs. This means checking the soil moisture regularly. For most common houseplants and garden plants, a good rule of thumb is to water when the top inch or two of soil feels dry to the touch. For very drought-tolerant plants like succulents, you might let the soil dry out more thoroughly between waterings. Conversely, plants that prefer consistently moist soil, like many tropicals or bog plants, may need watering before the soil fully dries out.
Developing a routine of checking your plants daily or every other day is a good practice. This allows you to observe them closely and learn their individual watering cues. Over time, you’ll develop an intuitive sense for when each plant is ready for a drink. Don’t be afraid to get your hands dirty – feeling the soil is the most reliable method.
Can I save a plant that has gone without water for a long time?
The chances of saving a plant that has been severely deprived of water depend heavily on how long it has been without water, the plant species, and the conditions it endured. While some plants are incredibly resilient, others are not.
For drought-tolerant plants, such as succulents, cacti, and many native arid-region plants, there’s a good chance they can be revived. If the plant appears completely dried out, with shriveled leaves or stems, the first step is to provide a thorough watering. For potted plants, you might even submerge the pot in a basin of water until the soil is fully saturated (you’ll see bubbles stop rising). Let excess water drain away completely. Place the plant in a location with bright, indirect light, avoiding direct sun initially, as a weakened plant can be susceptible to sunburn. Avoid fertilizing immediately, as this can stress an already compromised root system. With patience, you might see signs of recovery, such as plumped-up leaves or new growth, within a few weeks.
For less drought-tolerant plants, the prognosis is more guarded. If the plant’s leaves are completely dry, brittle, and falling off, and the stems are withered and brown, it may be too far gone. However, even in these cases, there’s sometimes a glimmer of hope. Check the base of the plant or the roots for any signs of life – green tissue, or firm, white roots (as opposed to brown, mushy, or brittle ones). If you find any signs of life, you can try the same revival techniques mentioned above: thorough watering, indirect light, and patience. Sometimes, cuttings from a seemingly dead plant can be revived if they are healthy enough.
It’s important to manage expectations. Not all plants can be saved, especially if they are sensitive species or have been deprived of water for an extended period under harsh conditions. However, a careful assessment and a gentle, patient approach offer the best chance for recovery. Remember that severe drought stress can weaken a plant, making it more susceptible to future problems, so continued careful watering and care are essential even after it appears to have recovered.
Why do some plants need more water than others?
The difference in water requirements among plant species stems from their evolutionary history and adaptation to specific environments. Plants have developed a diverse toolkit of strategies to manage water availability, leading to vastly different needs:
- Native Habitat: Plants originating from rainforests or humid temperate regions typically have high water needs because their native environments are consistently moist. They have evolved to thrive in such conditions and may have broad, thin leaves designed for efficient photosynthesis in lower light, but also for higher transpiration.
- Arid and Semi-Arid Climates: Conversely, plants from deserts or Mediterranean climates have evolved numerous adaptations to conserve water and survive prolonged dry periods. These include:
- Water Storage: Succulents and cacti store water in their leaves, stems, or roots.
- Reduced Leaf Surface Area: Small, needle-like, or absent leaves minimize water loss through transpiration.
- Thick Cuticles: A waxy outer layer on leaves and stems reduces evaporation.
- Deep Root Systems: Many plants develop extensive root systems to reach deep underground water sources.
- CAM Photosynthesis: Some plants, like cacti, open their stomata (pores for gas exchange) only at night when temperatures are lower and humidity is higher, significantly reducing water loss.
- Dormancy: Many species have a period of dormancy during the hottest or driest months, shutting down most metabolic activity and drastically reducing water needs.
- Growth Rate and Life Cycle: Fast-growing plants, especially those that produce abundant flowers or fruits, generally have higher water demands to fuel their rapid metabolic processes. Annual plants, which complete their life cycle in one season, often have high water needs during their growth phase to mature quickly.
- Leaf Structure and Transpiration Rates: Plants with large, thin leaves tend to transpire more water than those with small, thick, or fuzzy leaves. The number and opening/closing behavior of stomata also play a crucial role in regulating water loss.
Understanding the plant’s origin and its typical adaptations is the best way to predict its water requirements. For instance, if you see a plant with plump, fleshy leaves, it’s a strong indicator that it stores water and prefers to dry out between waterings. If a plant has large, thin leaves and comes from a tropical region, it’s likely to need more consistent moisture.
How can I help my outdoor plants survive a heatwave or drought?
Heatwaves and droughts can be incredibly stressful for garden plants, even those considered moderately drought-tolerant. Proactive measures can make a significant difference in their survival and well-being.
-
Water Deeply and Strategically:
- Timing is Key: Water in the early morning (before 10 AM) or late evening (after 4 PM) to minimize evaporation. Morning watering allows plants to hydrate before the heat of the day and prevents fungal diseases associated with prolonged leaf wetness overnight.
- Deep Watering: Instead of light sprinklings, water deeply to encourage roots to grow down into the soil, where moisture is more consistent. You want the water to penetrate at least 6-8 inches into the soil. A slow, steady trickle from a hose at the base of the plant is more effective than a quick blast from a sprinkler.
- Check Soil Moisture: Don’t water on a schedule. Feel the soil a few inches down. If it’s dry, water. If it’s still moist, hold off.
-
Mulch, Mulch, Mulch:
- Apply a 2-3 inch layer of organic mulch (wood chips, straw, shredded bark) around the base of your plants, keeping it a few inches away from the stems to prevent rot.
- Mulch acts like a blanket, insulating the soil from extreme heat, reducing evaporation, and retaining moisture. It also suppresses weeds, which compete for water.
-
Provide Shade:
- For sensitive plants, especially vegetables and young shrubs, temporary shade can be a lifesaver. You can use shade cloth, old sheets, or umbrellas to protect them during the hottest parts of the day.
- Consider planting more heat-tolerant species in areas that receive full sun and moving more delicate plants to spots with partial shade.
-
Avoid Fertilizing:
- Do not fertilize during a heatwave or drought. Fertilizers encourage new growth, which requires more water, and can burn the roots of a stressed plant. Wait until conditions improve and the plant shows signs of recovery.
-
Prune Selectively:
- Remove any obviously dead or severely damaged branches. However, avoid heavy pruning, as the remaining leaves help shade the plant and cool it down through transpiration.
-
Consider Watering Systems:
- If you live in a drought-prone area, consider installing a drip irrigation system or soaker hoses. These deliver water directly to the root zone, minimizing waste and maximizing efficiency.
-
Group Plants Together:
- For container plants, grouping them together can create a microclimate with higher humidity, which helps reduce water loss.
By implementing these strategies, you can significantly improve your outdoor plants’ ability to withstand and recover from periods of intense heat and drought.
The Art and Science of Plant Hydration
Ultimately, understanding “how long can plants go without water” is less about memorizing a specific number of days and more about developing an observational skill and a deep appreciation for the intricate ways plants manage their water resources. It’s a dance between the plant’s inherent capabilities and the environmental conditions it faces. Whether you’re nurturing a prized orchid, a robust vegetable garden, or a simple desk plant, paying attention to its subtle cues and providing the right amount of care at the right time is the secret to its long-term health and vitality.
My Arizona adventure with my aunt’s cactus was a powerful lesson. It wasn’t just that the cactus was tough; it was that it was *designed* to be tough, perfectly suited to its environment. We, as plant custodians, can learn so much by observing nature and understanding these adaptations. By applying this knowledge, we can cultivate thriving green spaces, no matter the challenges of the climate.
It’s a continuous learning process, and I’m always amazed by the resilience and adaptability of the plant kingdom. So next time you’re worried about your leafy companions, remember to check the soil, consider the conditions, and trust in your plant’s amazing ability to communicate its needs. With a little bit of understanding and a touch of care, most plants can endure quite a bit more than we might initially think.